However, despite Board approval last November that TVA could take steps to ensure all of the alternatives were an option based on timing, it does not appear that TVA took any actions to get Alternatives B or C underway. This decision is based on a thorough environmental and public review process that ensures we meet the growing energy needs of this region.. The power plant is in Cumberland City, Tennessee, 45 miles northwest of Nashville.. Cumberland: TVA executed a precedent agreement with Kinder Morgan/Tennessee Gas Pipeline to explore the option of using a newly built 32-mile, 30-inch gas pipeline to be generally located along an existing power transmission corridor to support a proposed 1,450 megawatt (MW) combined-cycle gas plant at the Cumberland site. Once that date has passed, you can still use the link to find more information on the Cumberland Plant closure. There will be a minimum 30-day period before TVA CEO,Jeff Lyash makes a final decision on whether to accept the recommendation. TVA Files Plan to Study Retirement of Cumberland Coal Plant In the fourth blog post of the series, we focus on the individual forecasts for each of the states in, On July 14, 2023, the District of Columbia Court of Appeals released a decision in our appeal of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's (FERC's) approval of the Southeast Energy Exchange Market, or, The Environmental Protection Agency has proposed what could be the first-ever limits on carbon pollution from most power plants. For more information, visitwww.sierraclub.org. We just cant know without the assumptions TVA used in the analysis. In recommitting to the Paris Climate Agreement, President Biden reasserted that all eyes are on America to lead again. Replacing retired generation with a natural gas plant is the best overall solution because its the only mature technology available today that can provide firm, dispatchable power by 2026 when the first Cumberland unit retires dispatchable meaning TVA can turn it off and on as the system requires the power, Lyash said. Replacement generation for the second unit has been deferred to allow consideration for a broader range of replacement options. While we understand that we need to be building as much renewable energy as possible to get off our dependence on fossil fuels, assuming too much solar and storage needs to be in place to retire this coal plant could unjustly make the cost and schedule of this alternative compare unfavorably to others. The project is owned by Tennessee Valley Authority. Cumberland coal plant with a natural gas facility, Fighting fossil fuel with fossil fuel: How natural gas is winning TVA's plan to end coal, TVA's next water permit for Bull Run could result in more pollutants in the Clinch River, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. The stacks no longer run constantly like they did when I was a child, and soon they will not run at all. the Cumberland coal units is part of TVA's ongoing strategy . TVA has pulled back on energy efficiency programs that reduce energy consumption and customer bills, and therefore misses a huge opportunity to offset some of the need for new generation to replace the Cumberland coal plant. If Lyash chooses gas, the plant's construction would begin in 2023 and should be operational by 2026. 10 Jan, 2023 TVA to replace Cumberland coal plant with 1,450 MW of gas-fired capacity Author Abbie Bennett Theme Energy The Tennessee Valley Authority intends to replace the first of two units at one of the largest operating coal plants in the U.S. with a new 1,450-MW combined-cycle gas plant, the federal power authority announced Jan. 10. Notably, the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) filed comments on TVAs draft EIS and worked as a coordinating agency in developing this final EIS. (See page 7 of our comments on TVAs 2019 IRP for a question about how SERVM is inappropriate to use in a planning study, such as this.). It is not too late to get TVA to change their minds. TVA is aggressively pursuing a sustainable, clean energy future while maintaining our commitment to providing affordable, reliable energy, said Jeff Lyash, TVA president and CEO. TVA is planning to retire all five of its coal-fired plants by 2035. You can contact her at anila.yoganathan@knoxnews.com, and follow her on Twitter @anilayoganathan. It consists of two coal-fired units: the first unit will be retired and replaced with a 1,450-megawatt combined cycle natural gas plant by 2026. TVA's push for gas over solar for Cumberland has been met with widespread criticism and questions not only from environmental groups but also from other federal agencies, such as the Department of Interior and the Environmental Protection Agency, when TVA first released its draft environmental impact statement. The last time we filed a similar FOIA, it took three months to get a response, and that response was woefully inadequate. TVA is planning to retire coal plants, what's next? - Clean Energy Adjusting just that one assumption could swing the cost difference enough so that the solar and storage scenario has a lower system cost than the gas CC. The DEIS shows that TVA chose the highest greenhouse gas (GHG) emitting alternative, yet it is touting this choice as beneficial on climate change because TVA compared it to the retiring coal plant instead of the other alternatives. Its not clear since no details are given on what kinds of wind were evaluated. It described the coal plants as "contributing to environmental, economic and reliability risks." The 1,662-page report released by TVA on Friday echoes a preliminary finding released in August that concluded TVA should shut down one of its aging coal units at Cumberland by 2026 and the. To get a 20-year NPV, a discount factor is applied to the annual system costs for each year to account for the assumption that money today is more valuable than money next year, which is more valuable than money the following, etc. Just a few weeks after failing fossil fuel plants caused rolling blackouts across its footprint, the Tennessee Valley Authority is recklessly plowing ahead with plans to spend billions on another dirty gas power plant, said Amanda Garcia, director of the Southern Environmental Law Centers Tennessee Office. Read more. Report Release: TVA Saves Billions By Choosing Clean Energy Entry Opportunities With Training - TVA.com This has been a long time coming and I have looked forward to gorgeous sunsets over the river and hills without the towering presence of the polluting smokestacks. Photo by Angie Mummaw. In some cases, like the eruption that happened in Whites Bluff in 1992, leaks can lead to potentially deadly explosions, threatening the lives of anyone nearby. The question Im getting a lot lately is: why does TVA want to build these gas plants? Likewise, the plants will be built so that carbon capture technology can integrated into the system if that technology matures and becomes cost-effective, Lyash said. Together were making a lasting impact across the Southeast. As it continues to retire it's coal plants, TVA is set to investigate whether the Kingston coal-fired plant will also be replaced by a natural gas plant. Alternative C: 3,000 MW of solar and 1,700 MW of storage. While renewables can provide intermittent energy to the grid, combined cycle natural gas plants can provide larger amounts of energy normally when TVA needs them to run. 0 There are other alternatives for replacing the plant. [12] Six of these use simple combustion turbines. [3] After Watts Bar Unit 2 began operation in late 2016, nuclear power passed coal as the top source of electricity. The Cumberland Fossil Plant is the largest generating asset in the TVA coal fleet and is located in Stewart County, Tennessee. The Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) filed a draft Environmental Impact Statement, or DEIS, last week to analyze the potential environmental impacts of various possible replacement options for its retiring Cumberland coal plant, and pick one of the evaluated replacement options as its preferred option. Cumberland Combined Cycle Gas Plant - GlobalData In his April 29 remarks on his first 100 days, President Joe Biden reiterated his commitment to moving the U.S.past fossil fuels to clean energy. Unless of course, the timeline is not so arbitrary because TVA is indeed trying to finalize this decision before it begins its next IRP. As described above, TVA ran a system-wide analysis to determine the difference in the system costs between the various alternatives. Were glad to see TVA retiring the Cumberland plant but leery of its desire to replace fossil fuels with more fossil fuels. In this DEIS, TVA proposes to retire one unit of the two units at the large coal plant in middle Tennessee between 2026 and 2030, and the other unit between 2028 and 2033. The municipality covers 604.3 km 2 (233.3 sq mi . Combustion turbines work like jet engines to power our generators. Published: Jan. 10, 2023, 4:16 p.m. By. &:=fXPKQ!V#sMC - Regardless, Lyash said on Tuesday that only natural gas can provide the reliable power needed to replace coal at the site. Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. You can share your opinions with decision makers until June 13, via public comment. There are currently over 250 people employed there, but a methane-fired plant would only create 25 to 35 permanent jobs. List of power stations operated by the Tennessee Valley Authority, "Tennessee - State Energy Profile Analysis", "Tennessee - State Energy Profile Overview", "U.S. utility TVA votes to close two coal power plants, in blow to Trump", "Tennessee Valley Authority plans to shut coal plants by 2035", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_power_stations_in_Tennessee&oldid=1148698929, Lists of buildings and structures in Tennessee, Lists of power stations in the United States, Short description is different from Wikidata, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 4.0, City of Covington Waste-To-Energy Gasification Plant, Chattanooga Metropolitan Airport Solar Farm, Chattanooga Metropolitan Airport Authority, This page was last edited on 7 April 2023, at 19:12. Now it's up to us: help us make positive environmental change, Be a champion for the environment. Through the upcoming EIS process, TVA will identify the timeline to retire the plants two coal units and if any replacement generation is needed. TVA has selected a combined cycle natural gas plant to replace the Cumberland coal-fired power plant. TVA Nears Decision to Build New Gas Plant and Pipeline in Middle I remember it being a huge deal when the plant was required to install smaller stacks with scrubbers to reduce the pollution. The actions TVA has taken to get the CC project underway have been very clear: TVA already entered into a precedent agreement with the pipeline company, which has allowed it to start the approval process at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). Currently, Kingston Fossil Plant is undergoing an environmental review to determine the potential impacts of retirement and replacement. Last week, TVA proposed to lock customers into paying for fossil gas to replace it, without fully exploring efficiency and renewable energy. Sierra Club 2023.The Sierra Club Seal is a registered copyright, service mark, and trademark of the Sierra Club. The owner, Randy Johnston, wants to expand his business by adding towing. TVA has committed to shutting down all of its remaining coal-burning plants. They want to burn another fossil fuel, one that would require the construction of a new plant and a 32-mile pipeline, cutting through the picturesque countryside of Stewart, Houston, and Dickson counties. TVA chooses gas plant despite EPA concerns - WBBJ TV The EPA found that TVA failed to properly evaluate alternatives like solar at the site, noting that the alternatives analysis continues to rely on inaccurate underlying economic information.. TVA's plans for future grid include more solar and natural gas TVA chooses natural gas to replace the Cumberland coal plant The journey from Crdoba to Seville costs just 15 if you stick to Media Distancia trains (not AVE). In early December TVA published its final Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) describing the environmental impacts of four options in regard to the Cumberland coal plant: The EIS claims Alternative A, the large gas plant at the same site as Cumberland, is the lowest-cost option. Another potential factor is that they see a window closing: if any utility is going to build new fossil infrastructure, it is only going to get harder in the future, so might as well push it through quickly. Angie is a community organizer for Appalachian Voices in Tennessee, supporting community members affected by the Cumberland City Plant closure. As a child, I remember the grim polluted smoke they gave off continuously throughout the day so much smoke that it made a dark trail all the way across the horizon. TVA has selected a combined cycle natural gas plant to replace the Cumberland coal-fired power plant. Lets talk about wind specifically. Special report:Tennessee's power generation is cleaner than ever. (TGP), una empresa de Kinder Morgan, Inc., present una solicitud ante la Comisin Federal Reguladora de Energa (FERC) para el Proyecto Cumberland propuesto por TGP (legajo assignado No. It consists of two coal-fired units: the first unit will be retired and replaced with a. The findings of this study allow performing a sustainability diagnosis of a large city such as Madrid, identifying energy needs, food consumption and manufactures as . I was sad to learn that TVA wants to install a methane gas-fired plant in its place. Assuming no growth and not adjusting for NPV means this is likely a conservative estimate. Under Lyash's decision-making, TVA took steps toward replacing one of Cumberland's two aging coal-fired units with a combined cycle natural gas plant . Remember that difference in the final EIS is now estimated to be $1.8 billion in 2021 dollars. TVA has not yet determined how it will replace the second unit. 2021 Appalachian Voices | Privacy Policy. Im proud of the Cumberland team, said Travis Patterson, Cumberland plant manager. 849 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<53B919291AA8C7438A0FD46F7632FE87>]/Index[826 38]/Info 825 0 R/Length 111/Prev 334818/Root 827 0 R/Size 864/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream Furthermore, the DEIS contradicts itself by claiming that Alternative A, the gas plant and pipeline option, allows the Cumberland coal units to retire sooner. 1001 Louisiana St., Suite 1000 TVA to replace its biggest coal plant with natural gas generation Environmental profile of the municipality of Madrid through the TVA's decision to stick with fossil fuels at Cumberland plant isn't Kinder Morgan Sign up to receive clean energy updates in your inbox. Removing an unreliable plant like Cumberland will rightly improve the coal availability metric that represents 5% of executives' annual bonuses. Well continue to do great work and Cumberland will remain an important part of the fleet until its slated retirement.. The EPA asked that TVA disclose the modeling and underlying assumptions in its analysis, and as discussed above, TVA chose not to share this information. Fighting fossil fuel with fossil fuel: How natural gas is winning TVA's plan to end coal. TVA has not published or shared any information about those assumptions and inputs, including how much demand for electricity TVA is forecasting, the assumed cost of building each type of resource, and the forecast for fuel prices especially fossil gas. TVA has yet to publish a draft EIS on the Kingston replacement, but we expect it to be very similar to the process to replace Cumberland: draft EIS, final EIS, then decision. However, TVA did not take into account that utility costs for distributed solar can be less than large-scale solar. Just because these resources cannot replace 100% of the capacity and energy needs of Cumberland does not mean they are not worth investing in at all. budget) and no discount of future funds, just keeping that $12.4 billion flat for 20 years, the difference between the two scenarios represents a cost difference of approximately 0.73% of TVAs total revenue. Maggie Shober | May 2, 2022 | Coal, Fossil Gas, Tennessee, Utilities Nowadays, the stacks give off big pillowy white puffs of smoke, which still pollute our atmosphere, whenever the plant is running. TVA will continue to evaluate the coal fleet for retirement and replacement generation. The Cumberland Fossil Plant is TVA's largest coal-fired power plant. The second unit will be retired by 2028. The Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) is the primary utility in Tennessee which generates electricity and sells it to hundreds of local utilities and industrial customers. El 22 de julio de 2022, Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, L.L.C. In response to several comments asking TVA to rerun the analysis to account for the passage of the IRA, TVA states in Appendix O that the IRA does not alter TVAs selection of the preferred alternative (Alternative A) nor does it change the least-cost planning analysis that led to TVAs adoption of the target supply mix in the 2019 IRP. In the final EIS, TVA claims a large portion of the cost difference between Alternatives A and C is that the solar and storage option requires investments in TVAs transmission infrastructure. The Cumberland coal plant is by no means young: its units were built in 1968 and 1973, but they are among the most recently built coal units in TVAs fleet. The DEIS TVA only considered large-scale solar as an alternative, dismissing distributed or rooftop and small-scale solar as an option because it is assumed to cost more. Voters are increasingly listing climate change as an urgent issue. The switch to natural gas will require the construction of a new 32-mile natural gas pipeline across Dickson and Houston counties, crossing over to the plant in Stewart County. 826 0 obj <> endobj In addition, natural gas supports continued reduction of carbon emissions by enabling the integration of renewables, such as solar and battery storage, all while maintaining system reliability.. The next step is a 'huge question', TVA chooses natural gas to replace the Cumberland coal plant, Fighting fossil fuel with fossil fuel: How natural gas is winning TVA's plan to end coal, failure of some natural gas plants in December, TVA takes 'full responsibility' for Christmas Eve power outages, rolling blackouts, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. TVA Retiring Cumberland, Continues Transition to Clean Energy Future TVA plans to replace Cumberland coal plant with another fossil fuel A list of power generating stations operated by the Tennessee Valley Authority : Dams and hydroelectric facilities [ edit] Apalachia Dam Bear Creek Dam Beaver Creek Dam Beech Dam Blue Ridge Dam Boone Dam Cedar Dam Cedar Creek Dam Chatuge Dam Cherokee Dam Chickamauga Dam Clear Creek Dam Dogwood Dam Douglas Dam Fontana Dam Fort Loudoun Dam (713) 369-9000, Copyright Kinder Morgan 2020-2023. The construction of the combined-cycle natural gas plant at Cumberland will deliver up to a 60 percent reduction in carbon emissions from the site. The EPA recommends TVA transparently disclose its modeling methodologies and assumptions to better enable a comparison between the alternatives. Mark J. Fite, Director of Strategic Programs Office at U.S. EPA, in a letter to TVA dated June 30, 2022. Achieving a 57 percent reduction in mass carbon emissions from the 2005 level one of the nations largest reductions while executing a path to 80 percent reduction by 2035. Anila Yoganathan is a Knox News investigative reporter. In 2021 TVA announced it would shutter the Cumberland coal plant. For the solar and storage option, Alternative C in the DEIS, TVA says it needs 3,000 MW of new solar and 1,700 MW of new storage to replace one of the Cumberland units today. He also pointed out that the environmental review process was limited to the Cumberland site, and failed to address changes TVA was making across its system. Under TVAs plan, smokestacks at the Cumberland Fossil Plant would continue to spew pollution into the air. Federal law requires TVA, a federal utility, to evaluate the environmental impact of shutting down a facility like Cumberland and evaluate possible replacements. The Cumberland Combined Cycle Gas Plant is a 1450MW thermal power project located in Tennessee, United States. But just to the south, Georgia Power just proposed a tall wind pilot project, and TVAs wind resources are better than Georgias. Energy security begins with diversification of energy sources, and TVA has one of the nations most diverse, cleanest energy systems, including nuclear, solar, hydro, gas and advanced technologies. El lateral de la tubera y las instalaciones asociadas se ubicaran generalmente paralelas y adyacentes a las servidumbres de servicios pblicos existentes. Tennessee Valley Authority - TVA Retiring Cumberland, Continues Together were making a lasting impact across the Southeast. TVA follows the National Environmental Policy Act a longstanding federal process which ensures public participation and input and a robust review of all feasible options. TVAs industry-leading decarbonization initiatives include: Natural Gas - TVA.com PDF Fossil Internal Tva Ups/ Fed Ex/ Etc. Addresses
Hebra Korok Seeds Tears Of The Kingdom,
Hamlin Horizon West News Today,
Sherwood Forest, Winston-salem,
Fivem Mdt Script, Esx,
Articles T
